More thoughts on Battlestar

August 14th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica, science fiction, telemovie

Aug
14

A friend of mine finally finished watching Battlestar Galactica, thanks to his Netflix membership and wrote me to tell me how much he and his wife loved the ending – and asking me a couple of questions about the finale.

I think about the finale often, I’ll admit, and I haven’t erased it off my DVR yet, though I haven’t watched it more than twice. I’ve gone back and forth from loving it to being disappointed in the last few minutes of it.

Battlestar Galactica

But as I wrote back to my friend, whom I’ll call S., I realized it really was the perfect ending. It is what the show was about all along. Fate. Destiny. Faith. Whatever the personal belief of the viewers, this is what the show was about.

The belief in the one true god was a dividing line between human and cylon from the miniseries itself. Not the only thing that separated them, but it wouldn’t be the first time religion exacerbated a rift between two cultures.

As I wrote, I realized I was putting an awful lot of thought into my answers, so  I thought I’d share his questions and my answers here, too. I’d love to hear what others think.

• First, S. wondered why Cavil killed himself. His wife thought it was because he believed he’d be resurrected on the base ship, but he disagreed. “I thought there was no further opportunity for resurrection. That’s why he agreed to let Hera go, after he was promised that the Cylons would re-create resurrection.”

He’s right, in fact. There was no further opportunity for resurrection, at least not until the Cylons figured it out again, and that seemed highly unlikely.

Cavil killed himself, I believe, because he saw that his time was at an end. I think he killed himself almost BECAUSE there was no resurrection, rather than it spite of there being no resurrection.

Read full story

2 Comments »

Dollhouse: Galactica?

August 7th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica, dollhouse

Aug
07

It was rather shocking to most, not least of all Joss Whedon, when Fox picked Dollhouse up for a second season.

Dollhouse

It never really got the ratings needed to get picked up. They weren’t soooo far off, however, so it wasn’t a foregone conclusion that it wouldn’t be picked up. It’s just that shows in this situation usually don’t. I think Fox was being penitent for having killed Firefly years ago.

We hadn’t watched it from the start, but had six or eight episodes already on our DVR by the time we started watching.

We plowed through them, and I was glad we watched it that way.

The first couple of episodes had a lot of background to lay down. Instead of having to wait weeks to start picking up the pace, we got there in a couple of nights.

Part of what started getting really good was Tahmoh Penikett’s character, the FBI agent, whose obsession with The Dollhouse began to ruin his career. He didn’t have the support of his co-workers and superiors, and he, eventually, is suspended.

picture-31

Penikett is a personal favorite of mine, having portrayed Helo on the late lamented Battlestar Galactica. So imagine how pleased I was when I found out through an article by my friend, Jennifer Wagner, that not one, but two other BSG veterans would be making appearances on Dollhouse in its surprise second season.

Jamie Bamber (Lee “Apollo” Adama) and Michael Hogan (Col. Saul Tigh) will have guest spots this season.

Joss Whedon had this interview with Access Hollywood to talk, in part about Bamber’s stint on the show. Apparently, it was the mutual admiration society.

As well it should be.

I’m loving the DNA mixing between my favorite shows. This can only result in great things.

4 Comments »

I heart Callum Keith Rennie

June 29th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica, callum keith rennie, harper's island

Jun
29

I first “met” this actor in Battlestar Galactica, in the pilot episode.

He played Leoben Conoy, trapped with Cmdr. Adama until he’s found out to be a Cylon and killed by the commander’s hand, in the pilot miniseries.

TIFF 2007 Portrait Session For Normal

We saw him again, now and then, over the course of the first couple of seasons, but really got to know him in Season 3, when he kept Kara captive in an apartment designed to look like hers back on Caprica. She kills him over and over and over again, and he just is reborn and goes back to her – with full knowledge of her murder of him.

By Season 4, he was full fledged crazy, but cool, convinced Kara was the answer to the question of life the universe and everything – and the question wasn’t “What is six times nine?”

I’d never seen Rennie before, but then I saw him again in one of the few almost decent episodes of the Bionic Woman remake. He was in an episode of Supernatural, which I just caught up on over the fall. He’s been in this, that and the other thing.

Then, just two weekends ago, he shows up in the very last minute of Harper’s Island, playing the really bad John Wakefield. He did it so well that I didn’t even recognize him until my husband pointed it out, as we were watching “The X-Files: I Want to Believe.”

I was stunned at how crappy this film was. And that Rennie was playing some menacing guy with a bad Russian accent.

Oh, Callum, how could you do this to me?

OK, it’s not your fault, really. I’m sure you agreed to do the film before you realized how awful it would be and then just didn’t want to go back on your word. Right?

4 Comments »

Battlestar Galactica: Classic v. Re-imagined

June 10th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica

Jun
10

I’ve been thinking altogether too much about Battlestar Galactica lately. Not sure why.

picture-31

Maybe because news has come out about The Plan telemovie. Maybe because Katee Sackhoff was cast in Season 8 of 24. Maybe because the Season 4.5 DVD drops next month. Maybe because I have the Caprica DVD sitting on the piano, mocking me for not having watched it yet.

Maybe just because I haven’t been able to cope with the fact that the series is over and it was just that frakkin’ good.

But I was thinking to myself about all the ways the new series was better than the old, and I realized that the old series doesn’t quite get its due among fans of the reimagining.

So I thought I’d do an old-fashioned matchup and see how the two stack up:

Read full story

10 Comments »

24 + Battlestar Galactica = Awesome

June 8th, 2009 | by | 24, battlestar galactica

Jun
08

It’s almost as if the Television Gods looked down upon Earth, said, “What casting decision could we make that would thrill Amy Vernon like no other?”

picture-11

Katee Sackhoff is joining the cast of 24 as a regular for Season 8.

Let me repeat: Kara “Starbuck” Thrace is going to be a CTU data analyst in the reconstituted CTU in New York City for Day 8.

Yes, I am getting a mashup of 24 and Battlestar Galactica. I’m the luckiest girl in the world!

Here’s what Michael Ausiello had to say:

Sources confirm to me exclusively that the Battlestar Galactica heroine has been tapped to play the series regular role of Dana Walsh, a highly respected and down-to-earth data analyst at the new and improved New York branch of CTU.

She’s in a relationship with fellow agent Davis Cole (played by the just-cast Freddie Prinze. Jr.), and she apparently has a skeleton in her closet she’s trying desperately to keep hidden.

Just wondering: Does CTU ever hire anyone who doesn’t have some sort of secret they’re desperately trying to hide? Remember Erin Driscoll’s schizo daughter?

7 Comments »

Battlestar Galactica: Eagerly awaiting The Plan

June 8th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica, telemovie

Jun
08

I’ve not ended the So Say We All blog carnival for simply one reason: Battlestar Galactica: The Plan – the BSG telemovie – airs in September and from what I read this weekend on SciFi Wire, it’s gonna be amazing.

picture-31

It’s written by Jane Espenson and directed by Edward James Olmos and it’s not exactly a secret what it’s about: It’s the Cylon perspective on basically the entire series. How and why the Cylons did what they did.

I think it’s a brilliant move because we pretty much were conditioned to believe the Cylons were just bad, unfeeling machines. Sure, they were given more humanity than the original BSG allowed, but in the end, they were bent on the destruction of humanity and, being human, that didn’t go over too well with us, the viewers.

Lest we forget, it was humanity who made the first move, by making slaves out of the machines. (I have the Caprica miniseries on DVD, by the way, and just haven’t had a chance to watch it. I’m hoping the slow summer season gives me the opportunity to watch it and finish Season 1 of Torchwood, too, but that’s another story for another day.)

Read full story

4 Comments »

Ratings: Worst. Season. Ever.

May 22nd, 2009 | by | ratings, season

May
22

OK, I guess the TV seasons before most people had televisions were worse, but this season was for the birds, according to The Hollywood Reporter.

tvs

The four major networks (that’d be CBS, NBC, ABC and Fox – sorry CW) lost an average of 16 percent of viewership in the coveted “demo” – adults 18-49. That includes DVR use.

Fox was on top, followed by CBS, ABC and NBC. But “on top” still includes a steep drop.

Why is this?

A whole mess of things.

First off, a lot of people are watching online – legally and illegally (Hulu an example of the former, BitTorrent an example of the latter). I know some folks who don’t have televisions, even, and only watch what they like online.

Second, a lot of people watch on DVR, but not within that 7-day window included in ratings. For example, my husband and I haven’t watched Season 2 of Damages yet. The entire season is sitting there on our DVR. We just finished up the entire first seasons of Dollhouse and Better off Ted in a few days in marathon viewing sessions. (I’ll be writing about BoT in a couple days). I still have episodes of Reaper, the season finale of Supernatural and Sunday’s episode of Breaking Bad on my DVR, waiting for me to have a chance to sit down and watch ‘em.

Read full story

4 Comments »

Supernatural: The beginning of the end?

April 12th, 2009 | by | supernatural

Apr
12

Now that Battlestar Galactica is over and I’m back from foreign lands, I thought I’d catch up with some of my favorite shows that have fallen by the wayside.

First up: Supernatural.

I’m not completely caught up, but I’ve watched all but last week’s episode, and I have to say it’s been fun hanging with the Winchester brothers again.

SPN (for those of us in the know) has just the right mix of horror, supernatural-ness and comedy, with a side order of beefcake.

picture-4

In watching “Death Takes a Holiday,” “On the Head of a Pin” and “It’s a Terrible Life,” I was struck by last week’s EW.com article about how Season 5 (next season) would be the last for the series – or, at least, the last with Eric Kripke at the helm and possibly the last with Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles.

The three episodes continued the “angels are among us and they’re really jerks” storyline begun earlier this season.

Read full story

6 Comments »

Battlestar Galactica: It’s all over (sniff)

April 6th, 2009 | by | battlestar galactica

Apr
06

I’ve had a very hard time blogging about the incredible finale of Battlestar Galactica, as most of you have likely noticed. (Not that Adam and Rickey have been harassing me about it. Not at all, not one little bit.)

But I truly think the finale ranks up there with the great series finales of all time, exemplified best in recent television history by The Wire and Six Feet Under.

picture-31

I still hardly know how to approach looking at the finale, so I thought I’d actually start with what I thought were the problems with it:

• Daniel was a red herring. No answer as to whether Daniel truly was Starbuck’s father and WHY she came back as an “angel” and why she was connected to “All Along the Watchtower.” (An interesting thought, though – the song was among the things that have happened before and will happen again, as Anders composed it way back on Earth, Starbuck’s father played it for her and it became popular on “our” Earth many thousands of years later.

• Who inspired the design/personality of the other Cylons? I’d have loved to have known more about Leoben and Sharon and Six and D’Anna and Simon and Aaron. We know Cavil was made in Ellen’s father’s image. And I’m fascinated that Six was one of the “angels” and so how did the Cylon model Six come to be made in that image?

• Why was Gaius an “angel”? How did he come to be born in that body? Was he truly a full human?

Those are all relatively minor issues, however.

So let’s look at how it all came to an end:

Read full story

7 Comments »