Lost: Follow the Leader

May 6th, 2009 | by | lost

May
06

Our favorite Lost characters tonight showed, once again, that you can’t change the past, no matter how hard you try.

Miles caused his father to kick his mother off the island.

Jack is going to cause the incident.

Locke kept the circle of the compass being passed around for all eternity going by having Richard Alpert give it to his pre-death self as he dug a bullet out of his leg.

Lost banner

I had kind of psyched myself up for a very Richard-centric episode; maybe finding out more about who and what Richard actually was. Initially, I thought we hadn’t learned very much. But in retrospect (an hour’s worth), I realize we learned something very important:

Richard is eternal.

We sort of knew it, of course. He has looked exactly the same every single time we’ve seen him. But we never really knew why and theorized about it left and right and thought time travel had something to do with it. Some have suggested that Richard is smokey, and after tonight I am beginning to think that’s the answer.

Richard’s always been around and it seems he’ll always be around. He knows more about the island than anyone; he’s the only one who knows how to find Jacob. But he’s never been in charge, even though he’s seemed to be in charge more than once.

He’s the consigliere, the “advisor,” as Ben put it. Does Ben know what Richard’s true nature is?

OK, look, even if he’s not actually Smokey, he’s something akin to or related to the smoke monster.

He’s not human in the same sense we are, that’s for sure.

So, what else did tonight make me think about?

• Why does Locke need to kill Jacob? And when he says “the island” told him all this stuff, what does that mean?

• Ben needs to watch what he’s doing when it comes to Locke, no? Didn’t Smokey’s appearance as Alex pretty much tell him not to screw with Locke? (Which might negate the theory of Richard being Smokey, now that I think about it.) He certainly seemed to be indicating to Richard that he was no supporter of Locke (not that that would be a secret).

• What’s Radzinsky’s deal, really? How is he able to basically tell Horace he’s not in charge anymore? He’s more than just some crazy paranoid guy; he has some true importance in Dharma that makes Horace unable to control him.

• How badly did you feel for Juliet when Kate came onto the sub? Totally sucks for Juliet; but I think that Sawyer truly does love Juliet.

• Sayid finally learns the one person he did not kill was Ben Linus. Poor guy; he killed all those people at Ben’s urging, and the one time he doesn’t finish the job, it’s when he tries to kill Ben.

• When Jack keeps insisting on how they need to make it all as if it never happened, is he completely ignoring the fact that that would mean Kate would go to prison for the rest of her life, or has he just completely forgotten? Or does he just not give a crap anymore? (I think that’s the most likely, and I have utterly joined the anti-Jack camp.)

If you don’t watch “coming next week” trailers, don’t read the rest of this oneOK? If you’re still reading, you watched the trailer: We see Sawyer, Juliet & Kate back on the island next week, so wtf is up with that? We know the submarine gets away from the island, because that’s how Miles & Charlotte ended up leaving.

Next week is “The Incident,” which we’ve wondered about for years, ever since we first saw “Marvin Candle” in the film in The Hatch. It’s the two-hour finale, setting us up for the final season ever of Lost.

Waaah.

Authored by

14 Responses to “Lost: Follow the Leader”

Show / Hide Comments
  1. Vernon Harmon says:

    The most important thing about Richard that we learned is that he doesn’t know everything. He didn’t know Locke had died. He didn’t know Ben was back.

    Locke is plugged into the Island now and he is going to kill Jacob because the island is tired of Jacob controlling things, presumably in ways that run counter to what the island really wants. Smokey is connected to the island, which is why it told Ben to follow Locke unfailingly. Richard doesn’t quite seem to have that same connection to the island. I suspect Richard is somehow tied to Jacob, not the island, which would explain how he could leave the island (we saw him recruit Juliet).

    –V.

  2. Locke is taking all of the Others to see Jacob. Told Ben he is going to kill Jacob. No one has actually seen Jacob except possibly Locke. Perhaps Locke is attempting to show them that there is no Jacob. “Killing him” is actually “killing” the notion that Jacob exists. Then Locke can truely rule the island and the trust of the Others and do whatever the hell he wants.

  3. AmyV says:

    @Vernon – Very interesting thoughts, and you’re absolutely right. Richard doesn’t know everything. He only seemed to know things he couldn’t have in the past because of what Locke told him in his past, most likely. What you said about Richard being connected to Jacob is fascinating, and I think you may well be correct.

    @Melandmaya – Interesting thought, but I respectfully disagree. Remember how Jacob said, “Help me” to Ben? And Jacob also appeared to be Christian Shepherd in that scene.
    Now, it’s entirely possible that he was faking the “help me,” which would play into what Vernon was saying above, about Jacob controlling the island in ways counter to what the island actually wants. In fact, the more I think about it, the more sense that makes. But I think that Locke does indeed mean to kill Jacob, whatever “kill” means for a being such as him.

  4. Vernon Harmon says:

    Didn’t Doc Jensen have some theory about Jacob being a timeloop-unstuck-in-time victim? Perhaps Locke “killing” him will be unlooping him and getting him stuck back where he belongs. It would explain why Jacob’s cabin vanishes, but not how Richard can find him at any time (if he actually can).

  5. Vernon Harmon says:

    Also interesting: if the island is feeding info to Locke, then why can’t Locke find Jacob himself? I suspect he *can* but is taking everyone along, including Richard, for some purpose.

    BTW, that was a frakkin cool scene when resurrected Locke sent Richard to heal timelooping Locke. Ben’s incredulous stare was priceless, as was Richard’s reaction to hearing Locke died.

  6. AmyV says:

    @Vernon – that’s a very interesting thought about unsticking Jacob. Very possible and yeah, would explain why Jacob’s cabin keeps moving. I think you may well be right about Locke being able to find Jacob and just pretending he can’t. I am beginning to think that Richard is the one connected to Jacob and neither is truly connected to the island.

  7. Nice post, and comments. I have nothing significant to add right now, but you guys rule. Next week is going to be so awesome!

  8. Donna says:

    Ben is so jealous of Locke. I think he is trying to set Richard up to do something to Locke since he can’t do it himself(because Alex – Smoke Monster told him to follow Locke)

    And I did feel so bad for Juliet… her face said it all. And I’ve been in the anti-Jack camp for a while. :)

  9. buffalonygal says:

    That totally makes sense about Jacob being stuck/unstuck in time…explains the vanishing and the request for help. I am totally boggled about Christian unless he is some representation of the Holy Trinity which ties into the notion of Jack as the messiah, Jacob as God and Christian the holy spirit?? No that seems far fetched but something along those lines??

  10. erika says:

    Honestly, I have no idea why so many people hate Jack, because I like him. Quite a bit, actually. I wonder what that says about me…

    It was great having an episode with most (all?) of the Losties doing something. I am not entirely convinced that Locke isn’t crazy, or that Jack is, but Jack does have Sayid on his side, so there’s that.

    I am really enjoying Richard Alpert. So glad that Cane show got cancelled way back so we could have Nestor Carbonell on the island all the time. I am extremely curious as to what his deal is.

    Also, I never liked Juliet until she hooked up with Sawyer. Now, all I want is for her and him to live happily ever after a la Penny and Desmond. So weird.

  11. AmyV says:

    Wow, lots to respond to:
    @Scott – thanks, and yes!!!
    @Donna – Interesting; I think that Richard must have been the one who turned against Richard & Eloise back in the way and that’s why they both ended up off the island (don’t forget, we only learned why Richard had to leave, not why Eloise did)
    @Buffalonygal – The only thing far-fetched about Lost theories is that anyone would consider them far-fetched, considering the show. :-) Very interesting thought, and you might be onto something.
    @Erika – I used to be pro-Jack. But I’ve just found him to be utterly insufferable and unable to get over himself in the last season or so. I’m totally with you on Juliet, though. Juliet and Sawyer are totally a Penny/Des romance for the ages. I wanted to punch out Kate when she got on the sub.

  12. AmyV says:

    Thanks for stopping by, Sheri – tonight should be awesome.

  13. [...] Spoiler Junkie…Monsters « Lost theories…Lost Episode 05-16 and 05-17 The Incident…Lost: Follow the Leader – TV Shows…Review: Lost Season 5 Finale – Associated Content | Latest Hot News & Videos…Season 6 teaser [...]

Leave a Comment